Open Question

asked by nfl100500
Should I keep or drop Jonathan Stewart from Carolina? I drafted him just for a backup RB.
8:16am Aug 16 from nfl100500
7 Comments
  • keep him

    9:00am Aug 16 from abbloom
  • keep. He is the lead back on Carolina and as your backup RB? A huge steal in my opinion

    9:31am Aug 16 from rosscoleman
  • keep

    2:37pm Aug 16 from joncuthbert
  • keep

    2:05pm Aug 16 from osudengaard
  • Keep him

    10:58am Aug 16 from nileshellmers
  • Yeah, if there isn't a better one you can pick up in free agency.

    8:26am Aug 16 from dierre15
  • lead back Is Williams now .Drop him

    4:29pm Aug 16 from moneymike73333

Answer More Open Question Questions

I Got Newton By Trying To Bid Up A Guy & Signed Flacco. How Do You Guys Think They Both Will Do Help
2:20am Jul 23 from darkraider00
Bye weeks for Ks, DEFs: what do you do? Do you play these games without Ks and DEFs or drop players?
1:50am Jul 23 from jirik2001
  • If I have a top 5 kicker (prater, gostkowski, etc)... I usually drop the weakest player on my team for a kicker at the last moment. Then after the sunday is over, I use that kicker to get either that player I dropped back or a better one. Idk about defenses... I play in an IDP league.

    1:56am Jul 23 from chillrays
Grade my team. (A B C D F)
10:39pm Jul 22 from hxcian
  • B

    Strong RBs, below avg WRs, but it's better to be that way than the reverse, as Top 10 RBs score more than Top 10 WRs. Also like Thomas

    The key to this team is gonna be Brady though. If Gronk is healthy and all those young WRs have made the progress they needed to this offseason, Brady could be in for a Top 5 finish, but if not he could end up outside the Top 10

    10:43pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • b

    12:10am Jul 23 from hanau
  • B I'd like to see a better WR2 than Torrey Smith but who knows.. this may finally be a solid season for him. Nice team otherwise.

    10:51pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
Question in comments
10:32pm Jul 22 from patsfan1120
  • I'd say no

    As nice as the thought sounds to add all those guys to your lineup, it will kill pretty much all chances you have of competing next year

    10:40pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • I get Megatron, Benjamin, Edelman, Stacy, 16-20 round draft picks next year. I lose woods, Hopkins, Mathews, 1-4 and 8 round draft picks next year. Who wins? 12 Team Dynasty league

    10:33pm Jul 22 from patsfan1120
  • I know theres 20 people here that reply to peoples comments on a consistent basis but let me speak for myself. Whenever you include future draft picks in your trades, I really don't know how to judge them. So if I only reply to your people for people trades in the future, don't be upset. Its all good though, enjoy your dynasty league.

    10:50pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
Who gets the better deal? Vernon Davis and Alfred Morris. Jason Witten,Andre Ellington,Reuben randle
10:29pm Jul 22 from herecomestheboom9
  • Guy getting Witten, Ellington and Randle

    10:41pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • Davis and morris

    12:11am Jul 23 from hanau
  • I'd rather have Alfred Morris and Vernon Davis.

    12:35am Jul 23 from chillrays
Load More
Dynasty keeper league, left with r wilson or larry Fitz to go along with Charles. Who do I keep?
10:03pm Jul 22 from lavertious429
  • I'd say Fitz, odds are you can draft a better QB than Wilson anyway

    10:37pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • Fitzgerald has an easy schedule this year... i'd keep him.

    10:28pm Jul 22 from chillrays
  • Wilson.

    10:19pm Jul 22 from jdizzle45
Load More
Is this a reasonable trade offer? I send T.Rich, E.Decker, J.Maclin, for brown(pit) white and tate
10:00pm Jul 22 from lamchop85
  • No, it's not

    I know if I'm the guy with Brown, White and Tate I do not take that trade

    Decker and Maclin are WAY worse than Brown and White, and no way you can convince me to take TRich over Tate, who has proven successful when healthy and is in for a starting role in Cleveland, after his dreadful 2013 season

    The guy will never take it

    10:38pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • Which Tate? Either way there is no way someone would do that trade!

    10:06pm Jul 22 from patsfan1120
  • no chance... only if your trade partner is an idiot to do that deal.

    10:28pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
Rank my team. (Surprise picks) 10 man team. Team in comments.
9:46pm Jul 22 from tcruz1
  • 7

    Great WRs, but only decent everywhere else, even RB as Gore is gonna Bust and Sankey is still unproven

    9:53pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • What kind of league are you in? are the rest of the managers 2 years old? You got McCoy, Bryant and Marshall

    12:59am Jul 23 from hanau
  • Yes, cut marvin jones or reily cooper for more bench running backs. Otherwise this is a great team.. I give it a B

    10:27pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
I have DeSean Jackson&Larry Fitzgerald I want to trade for Antonio Brown&Jordy Nelson. Do it or nah?
9:32pm Jul 22 from tcruz1
  • Yeah but who in their right mind would do that trade?

    9:54pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • yes

    9:34pm Jul 22 from mchugh015
  • yes if u can manage to pull that deal off

    10:27pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
Trade Lynch, Gronk, Harvin for Peterson, Watkins, H. Miller? Would have McCoy and AP as my rbs lol
9:23pm Jul 22 from austindangerpowers
  • Looks kind of idiotic, but just the thought of Peterson and McCoy in the same backfield in a 12 team league is insane

    9:25pm Jul 22 from austindangerpowers
  • Don't do it, you'd be way too weak at TE and Watkins is way worse than Harvin

    10:36pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • That would be nice but lynch and McCoy are solid starters. You would be taking a major downgrade from TE though. So I would have to say NO to that deal

    9:26pm Jul 22 from patsfan1120
Load More
What do you think about the Saint DEFENSE? Is it a Top 3? May I draft it insted of the SEAHAWKS
8:40pm Jul 22 from ignacio137
  • It's startable, that's about it

    10:36pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • Not a top 3. And i think this is not comparable with the Haks Def at all.

    8:49pm Jul 22 from rigor973
  • won't be top 3 for a little while to come. I say they are a safe top 15 but thats just my opinion.

    8:46pm Jul 22 from chillrays
Load More
Want to Trade Djax, Fitz & Dez who to seek? Megatron, AJGreen, D. Thomas, Nelson, A.Brown, K. Allen?
8:22pm Jul 22 from cruz4329
  • Keep Dez, package DJax and Fitz together to get Green or Thomas

    10:33pm Jul 22 from zgamer200
  • Keep Dez.

    8:24pm Jul 22 from oo75
  • I wouldnt let AJ green go neither Megatron so try with thomas and nelson

    8:32pm Jul 22 from ignacio137
Load More